Account review: anonymised client
ExampleThe short version
The account is profitable but stuck. 80% of spend sits on four ads from the summer, and nothing new beats them because tests get £20 a day. Fix the testing structure first, then the creative pipeline.
Keep
The broad prospecting campaign: 70% of purchases at the best CPA.
Cut
Interest ad sets that overlap broad. Higher CPA, same people.
Test next
A testing campaign with its own budget, and three angles from your reviews.
Scorecard
| Area | Rating | What we found |
|---|---|---|
| Account structure | Needs work | 9 campaigns for £15k a month. Most ad sets spend under £20 a day and never leave learning. |
| Bidding and budgets | Good | Highest volume suits the spend. Budgets move no more than 20% at a time. |
| Creative | Fix first | Four ads take 80% of spend. The newest winner is from June. All talking-head video. |
| Landing page | Needs work | Price and reviews sit below the fold on mobile. The subscription option is hidden. |
| Tracking | Good | Pixel and Conversions API both firing and deduplicated. |
| Audiences and exclusions | Needs work | Subscribers aren’t excluded from prospecting. |
Quick wins
- Exclude subscribers and 180-day purchasers from prospecting.
- Turn off the three ads above £45 CPA. About £1,200 a month goes back into the ads that work.
- Move price per cup and reviews above the fold on mobile.
What we’d test next
| Test | Why | How we’d judge it | Budget and time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Angle: “roasted the week it ships” | Top theme in 5-star reviews, not in any ad yet | CPA against the best current ad | £1,500, 10 days |
| Format: us vs them static | Cheapest to make, and the comparison sells the price per cup | Click-through, then CPA | £1,000, 7 days |
| Offer: free tin over £45 | Order value is £36. A threshold above it lifts basket size | Contribution per order after ad costs | £2,000, 14 days |